“If you need help, DON’T go to a Mennonite”

I just received a post from a man in Pennsylvania who is responding to an essay on “Dehumanization of the Homeless” on the Mennonite Poverty Forum. (This post is edited some, so if you want to read the full post in its context, please go to: http://groups.google.com/group/mennonite-poverty-forum/browse_thread/thread/b4a61d17a32cbe4a)

How would you respond to this? What does this say about Mennonites in general?

Here in my area the Mennonites control my county in all legal aspects and purposely made an ordinance so the poor can no longer eat out of garbage bins at the backs of stores so the food that is edible but past date is left to rot while people go hungry.

Mennonites will never join or become part of your group At least the Mennonites from Lancaster County, PA They are part OF the problem you speak of and work their best to extract every ounce of flesh from the homeless and those who have next to nothing I know I have eaten with the homeless as I am near homeless myself due to physical illness and have seen the inhumanity and how the mennonites and amish treat those in need.

The only people in my area that do a THING for the homeless are the Catholics and that is mostly lip service and a free bowl of cereal but at least that is something!

In my area there is a saying: If you need a helping hand DONT ask an Amish person or a Mennonite and I know I have lost most of my worldly possessions due to Mennonites who raised me and stole my money after I let them have power of attorney over my money.
(sorry for the generalization as Im sure there are good Mennonites some where but NO where in Lancaster County as they are suspicious, haughty and own most of the businesses here while exploiting non-mennonites in the worst fashion) If there was anything to helping others dont you think you would have a more active group here?
Im sure there are decent folks who are mennonites but NOT in my area, and if you asked nearly ANY non-mennonite on the street in my area about mennonites you would find the exact same sentiment I have expressed only in more vulger terms
Why bother with the charades? Simply for your unwarranted tax exempt status?
You Do absolutely NOTHING for those, in this country, who are less fortunate around you and only look on them as objects to abuse We have homeless people beaten and taken advantage of nearly every week here and it is too often done by young Mennonite ‘toughs’ from outside the city environs who come in on weekends and drink till they are drunk i the city bars then go out and look for helpless people to abuse.

In fact, most city people who are of color or nationality other than white germanic descent here are AFRAID to wander outside the city much at night due to Mennonite ‘toughs’ who inhabit the small towns outside the city and prey on anyone from outside their own clique The only areas safe are the ‘amish tourist strips’ which dominate this county and are owned and operated by amish and mennonites to extract oney from tourists who come to see the ‘amish’ people but see only a weird facade of tourist traps
Im white and even I avoid Mennonites due to their violent and self-serving tendencys since I know if I get into an altercation their inherited money will protect them from any violent actions they would pursue What good is your facade of a group you are trying to form anyway?

Instead of posting here get out and help people and show the world there are GOOD kind decent mennonites and not just those mennonites who want to abuse others who are less fortunate than they are .

Comments (8)

  1. SteveK (Post author)

    Well, it’s only kinda interesting that this post didn’t rate even a single comment or response. For anyone interested, there are some facinating responses by conservative Mennonites on this site:


    Steve K

  2. Esther Castro

    I was shocked to read your post on the Mennonites in Lancaster County and I am sorry if you experienced victimization. My experience of Mennonites in Lancaster County years ago was so different. We are people of color and we were welcomed and treated with kindness when we stayed in their homes. However, that is going back 45 years or more and one thing I know about any society- it is not static. Also, it cannot be immune to the society it is in. In many cities the wealthier citizen’s have taken the same stance in trying to stop the homeless from being so “visible”. I hope someone in your local area will reach out to you with kindness.

  3. Daniel Freysinger

    My family spent many years with conservative Mennonites as we tried to find our place in the Church. We were shown respect by most of the Mennonites with whom we came in contact. There was an occasional personality conflict, but I tend to be a bit aggressive.

    It is important that people realize the Amish and Mennonites are fallible people just like everyone else. We have jobs that frustrate, kids that rebel and cars that break down. We say things we wish we could take back and we sin when we wish we wouldn’t.

    It breaks my heart that this person has had such a negative experience. I wish I could introduce him to a young couple that befriended me early in my seeking days. They are both from Lancaster and I have rarely met more gracious, Christ honoring people.

  4. Cheryl

    Yeah I use to go to a Mennonite Church also ! Alot of them are very evil and pretend to be good! The younger Mennonites now a days are selfish,stand offish ,rude ,And if you are not one of them will not help you! Maybe years ago but this generation of them is very evil!

    1. Paul Wendel

      Two coats apiece ?
      The modern Mennonites have all kinds of disguises for the getting of gain.

  5. a.

    Yes, I live in the Fraser Valley and it is filled with Mennonites and they abuse the homeless here too! It is called the “least Christian Christian city.” Also, if you are looking for a Church home they won’t invite you. Also, they won’t throw you a baby shower or visit you in the hospital–but they’ll gladly take whatever it is that you are offering them. Honestly, the rudest people you will ever meet. I’m curious about the tax exempt status–around here the Mennonites control most of the Churches. They have taken to calling these Churches “community Churches” and pretend they are open to everyone. Except these Churches aren’t. The more honest Mennonites will admit they don’t want outsiders there. So, why call them “community” Churches? This is a widespread problem–they will pretend to be inclusive but they aren’t. I’d like to see something written on this. We have a Mennonite young pastor around here who has a blog called “the road to dapper”–google it. Honestly, I’ve never seen anything so shallow. Around here homelessness is an increasing problem because out of control housing prices–and he is more concerned with being dapper! and wearing nice clothes. I just don’t get it. Someone please explain this all to me. Are the Mennonite Churches just tax shelters, ways to employ family members? what is the deal?

  6. Kathy Owen

    I was in shock a couple of winters ago when buisnesses and others in our town in Colorado were collecting food for the homeless. People were wonderful till we entered the import store owned by the mennonites. There we were rudely informed that they would donate nothing because they didn’t enable homeless people by feeding them. They buy items from poor starving villagers in Africa but don’t believe in helping people in need here. I was shocked. Made me wonder if their idea of helping the poor over seas is actually just exploitation.

  7. James Brewer

    My daughter bought a old trailer to rebuild however this trailer has be broke into wiring stole water tank and breaker she has lost her eyesight so she cannot afford to put it together we’d here can I find help for


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *